43 replies to this topic

[RedScarlett]

I thought a thread had been created about this, but my search suggests not.
What bands do you think have undeserved attention, and which do you think do not get the credit they deserve?

Overrated: Coldplay
Underrated: 30 Seconds to Mars

[MB13]

underrated: sunny day real estate
overrated: the thousands of bands influenced by them

[choke me]

Umm
I always say alot of bands are over rated but cant think of many right now
hmm

Overrated: Kanye West
Underrated: DFA1979

[echobrain]

Overrated: Franz Ferdinand

Underrated: Echobrain

[7Corners]

Overrated: Fallout Boy
Underrated: Coheed & Cambria

[Lyz9]

Now, this is all just in my humble opinion because I know others won't agree.
Overrated: Dave Matthew's Band
Underrated: Lloyd Dobbler Effect

[Fairy55]

Overrated: Fallout Boy
Underrated: Coheed & Cambria

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

100% agreed!!

overrated: Green Day (new stuff)
underrated:Panic! At the Disco

ahh! dont yell at me for green day..
u can disagree if u want
just dont freak out.

[neogeo]

Overrated: Coheed & Cambria
Underrated: Dredg

[st-Jinny]

overrated: Nirvana (sorry, don't yell at me anyone)
underrated: 30STM

[Proxen]

Overrated: All of MTV
Underrated: Opeth

[Scarlet713]

overrated: Fallout Boy
underrated: 30STM

[bbogert]

Overrated: My Chemical Romance (I know that one's going to piss off a lot of people)
Underrated: The Afghan Whigs (disbanded in 2001 unfortunately)

[4everinblujeans]

under rated

DREAD ZEPPLIN!

[Joice_Pink]

i cant stand kanye west..he is such a jerk

[Fairy55]

Overrated: My Chemical Romance (I know that one's going to piss off a lot of people)
Underrated: The Afghan Whigs (disbanded in 2001 unfortunately)

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

GASP!!!!!
hahaha
I love MCR  oh so very much!
LOL
But it doesnt piss me off when others dont.
U can have ur opinion too
And i respect that
I went backstage to meet them a few weeks ago :-)
Theyre pretty nice guys

[bbogert]

GASP!!!!!
hahaha
I love MCR  oh so very much!
LOL
But it doesnt piss me off when others dont.
U can have ur opinion too
And i respect that
I went backstage to meet them a few weeks ago :-)
Theyre pretty nice guys

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Yeah, after seeing your MySpace, I had a feeling you might feel obligated to respond to that one.  

[Fairy55]

Yeah, after seeing your MySpace, I had a feeling you might feel obligated to respond to that one. 

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

LOL
i just HAD to
hehe

[7Corners]

Overrated: Coheed & Cambria
Underrated: Dredg

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Guess prog-rock isn't your style...either that or you can't get past Claudio's unique voice.

[bbogert]

Guess prog-rock isn't your style...either that or you can't get past Claudio's unique voice.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

I still can't picture that voice coming out of that man... Even watching them live... Something just isn't kosher...

[7Corners]

I still can't picture that voice coming out of that man... Even watching them live... Something just isn't kosher...

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

I do my best not to question...one thing is for sure though...the guy has disgustingly good range.